When the surgeon and the nutritionist don't agree

[Drasan 23]

Who do you listen to when the surgeon and the nutritionist do not agree on the pre-op diet?

[elcee 3,341]

The surgeon. They are the one that's operating on you so I would want to make sure that i followed their advice.

[mom.on.the.go 0]

surgeon. both pre-op and post-op. there was a lot of discussion at the support group down here a couple weeks ago about how even the nutritionists in the same office serving the same patients don't agree among themselves.

the surgeon is "responsible" for the gadget. he is king. lol.

[Jachut 487]

For the post op diet - I'd definitely rely on the surgeon's advice.

for all else, the nutritionist. But even then, I'd make my own decisions based on my own beliefs becuase being a nutritionist is a lot like being a personal trainer - you work according to your own beliefs and those are based only really on current trends, not absolute medical proof that what they advise is best. Ten years from now, their advice will probaby be outdated. Anything works if you do it consistently - low carb, low fat, low calorie, etc.

[Drasan 23]

Thank for your repsonses, they make a lot of sense.

I was a bit surprised by the conflicting information from the surgeon and the nutritionist. I plan to speak with the surgeon about it when I see him again to schedule surgery.

Thanks again!