why did I pb from soup?

[Just Banded 0]

I'm 4.5 in about 9.75 cc band

just pbed on pacific food's creamy Tomato Soup

I really didn't think it was possible to pb on Soup since I thought it went thru!

If you are familiar with this soup- it's not really that "thick"

I can't be that tight- I ate bbq turkey yesterday!

Edited January 10, 2009 by Just Banded

[Weas123 0]

Soup? That dosen't sound right... I think you should call your doctor becuase you might be overfilled...

[kimmyv 0]

Honestly-- Isn't it SO random what can make you PB...

I actually can eat steak, lettuce and celery if I take appropriate sized bites and chew well. But Soup just hits me wrong. I think maybe because I swallow too fast or eat more of it at a time... Not sure but soup is not something that I can tolerate very well. And I love cream of Tomato.

You've done great by the way....Our starting stats are pretty similar. Are you low BMI? I joined Daily plate today to get a better handle on where my calories etc are coming from. I am losing REALLY slow. Hopefully getting a treadmill tomorrow so that should help. And I need another fill I think....