Protein Cookie?

[hmills653 365]

So I found these Cookies today. They are called "My Cookie". They have 18 gms Protein, I was so focused on the protein that I didn't pay attention to the carbs. What's your input. Are these ok, or finish them and find something different.

[Healthy_life2 8,324]

We are adults. We make our own choices.

My instructions from my dietician. Add healthy carbs after I lost 75% of my weight. The carbs added are to slow or stop weight loss for maintenance phase. Surgeons offices seem to give different instructions.

I was allowed Quest bars by the dietician..Nutrition facts below.Note Bottom of label. Says 3 active carbs? I have no idea about that.

Ingredients for my cookie below.

[Amburmist 55]

So I found these Cookies today. They are called "My Cookie". They have 18 gms Protein, I was so focused on the protein that I didn't pay attention to the carbs. What's your input. Are these ok, or finish them and find something different.

36g of carbs is the max im supposed to have in a day. So to eat it in one sitting wouldnt be so good. Same with the Quest bar. My NUT said those Protein Bars arent very good for us, that theres plenty of other healthy Snacks out there without so many carbs. To each his own, tho. I guess id rather just eat a regular cookie, which probably doesnt have anywhere near that level of carbs, and be done with it. They tell u that sometimes...that diet products can be worse than the full fat ones!

[PAstudent 117]

35 minutes ago, jenn1 said:

Note Bottom of label. Says 3 active carbs? I have no idea about that.

Those are the "net" carbs. Many people don't include Fiber or sugar alcohols when counting carbs so they'll subtract the fiber and sugar alcohols from the total carbohydrates listed.

[Healthy_life2 8,324]

1 minute ago, PAstudent said:

Those are the "net" carbs. Many people don't include Fiber or sugar alcohols when counting carbs so they'll subtract the fiber and sugar alcohols from the total carbohydrates listed.

Thanks!

[Healthy_life2 8,324]

7 minutes ago, Amburmist said:

36g of carbs is the max im supposed to have in a day. So to eat it in one sitting wouldnt be so good. Same with the Quest bar. My NUT said those Protein bars arent very good for us, that theres plenty of other healthy Snacks out there without so many carbs. To each his own, tho. I guess id rather just eat a regular cookie, and be done with it. They tell u that sometimes...that diet products can be worse than the full fat ones!

I try to eat whole food most day's. But dang, I have a Quest protein chip addiction.

[I guess id rather just eat a regular cookie, which probably doesn't have anywhere near that level of carbs,]

[Amburmist 55]

I try to eat whole food most day's. But dang, I have a Quest Protein chip addiction.

I hear ya. I think its that crunch we're craving. Since i cant have crackers or chips or really anything "carby" until 6 months post, i ceave things too, so i dont blame ya. Im having a pickle right now to try and staunch my crunch craving, even though its salt content is probably drying me out something fierce!

[Healthy_life2 8,324]

Just now, Amburmist said:

I hear ya. I think its that crunch we're craving. Since i cant have crackers or chips or really anything "carby" until 6 months post, i ceave things too, so i dont blame ya. Im having a pickle right now to try and staunch my crunch craving, even though its salt content is probably drying me out something fierce!

love pickles!

[hmills653 365]

It's not that I really want a cookie. I just thought it might be a nice alternative to a traditional Protein Bar. I'm just looking for higher Protein options bc I know that I'm not getting enough in. Also my nut never gave me specific numbers for the carbs, just protein 60 gms.

[Mattymatt 491]

2 hours ago, hmills653 said:

So I found these Cookies today. They are called "My Cookie". They have 18 gms Protein, I was so focused on the Protein that I didn't pay attention to the carbs. What's your input. Are these ok, or finish them and find something different.

This does not look nutritious at all. Yes, it's high in protein but it is still relatively high in carbohydrates and calories. As an occasional snack, I think it's not bad but I wouldn't make this a daily thing.

[KarenOR 180]

3 hours ago, Amburmist said:

I hear ya. I think its that crunch we're craving. Since i cant have crackers or chips or really anything "carby" until 6 months post, i ceave things too, so i dont blame ya. Im having a pickle right now to try and staunch my crunch craving, even though its salt content is probably drying me out something fierce!

Kay's has a bunch of pretty good Protein Snacks for the crunch. I bought some of the white cheddar and thought they were good .

[Amburmist 55]

Kay's has a bunch of pretty good Protein Snacks for the crunch. I bought some of the white cheddar and thought they were good .

Oh, thank u!! I may have to try them, as long as the carb content is also low.

[Amburmist 55]

Also my nut never gave me specific numbers for the carbs, just Protein 60 gms.

Heres what numbers my team has given me for guidelines, PER DAY:

Calories: up to 600
Protein: 60-80g
Fat: less than 25g
Carbs: less than 60g -- Net Carbs: less than 35g (regular Carbs minus Fiber = Net Carbs)
Fiber: up to 25g
Water: at least 64oz
Sugar: Wasnt given sugar gram guidelines.

Exercise: 30-60 mins (or 150-300 mins/week - a week being 5 days)

Hope this helps. Seems to be working fine for me. Though, I'm sure everyone one on this app has been given different numbers for their micros, since each doc/nutritionist has their own idea of dieting success. These numbers are just recommendations based on my team. Tweek ur daily numbers as ur body sees fit is always the best plan of attack! Good luck!

[Winny7556 3]

I have a question then, not Cookies, but rather about carbs. What about lentils and fruit? My dietitian says that without carbs, we'll crash. So I avoid breads and pastas and stick to Beans, lentils, vegetables and fruit. I'm not losing crazy weight, but I'm still losing 10 lbs a week. More manageable loss I guess.

Sent from my SM-G930W8 using BariatricPal mobile app

[summerset 5,265]

On 10.11.2017 at 11:10 PM, jenn1 said:

[I guess id rather just eat a regular cookie, which probably doesn't have anywhere near that level of carbs,]

Doesn't have that amount of Protein as well.

Protein Cookies or brownies are very filling. I used to eat them in the beginning (got tired of them after a few weeks though).

I don't buy into this "might as well eat"-mentality. Black and white. With protein cookies or brownies you eat only one - and that's it. With regular cookies... well, I suppose there might be room for a few others after the first?

I also don't get the hype about Quest bars. They taste like pure artificial sweetener to me. *YUCK*