HELP! Hating all protein shakes

[HeatherS. 230]

38 minutes ago, 1poundatatime said:

I was totally fine with the shakes until one day last week. I simply couldn't choke it down. I threw the last of it out. The thought of taking another sip was nauseating.

So, I'm experimenting and seeing how much Protein I can take in without them. Hopefully it will be enough, because I honestly don't think I can handle any more Protein Powder.

I'm struggling with it. Unlike others, I can taste the Unjury strongly through almost anything. I'm going to try making some loaded mashed potatoes tonight with aged cheddar and spices and see if that does the trick.

[HeatherS. 230]

43 minutes ago, 1poundatatime said:

I found the best way to mix them is in a shaker cup. Any container with a good lid will do. A quick shake works better than any amount of stirring.

So they froth as much in a shaker cup? I've been having a tough time with the froth, too.

[S Ann 8]

I can only stand the premade liquid premier chocolate frim Amazon that comes in tetra pacs. Everyrhing else I've tried was abysmal.

[Melena68 40]

My surgery date is 9 May. I have been trying different kinds of Protein Drinks to see which one I like best. I like the Premier Protein pre-made chocolate and vanilla. I have heard that your taste for things changes after surgery. I hope I can still drink this because all the others were not my fave. I like the Isopure, but it is super expensive.

[1poundatatime 174]

1 hour ago, HeatherS. said:

So they froth as much in a shaker cup? I've been having a tough time with the froth, too.

After I drink one, I mix the next and leave it in the fridge until I'm ready to drink it. Seems to be smoother that way.

[1poundatatime 174]

1 hour ago, Melena68 said:

My surgery date is 9 May. I have been trying different kinds of Protein Drinks to see which one I like best. I like the Premier Protein pre-made chocolate and vanilla. I have heard that your taste for things changes after surgery. I hope I can still drink this because all the others were not my fave. I like the Isopure, but it is super expensive.

For me at least, it wasn't that my tastes changed, I just hit a wall after so many weeks of Protein Shakes that I can't bear to drink another sip.

[smileeangel 9]

I was totally fine with the shakes until one day last week. I simply couldn't choke it down. I threw the last of it out. The thought of taking another sip was nauseating.

So, I'm experimenting and seeing how much Protein I can take in without them. Hopefully it will be enough, because I honestly don't think I can handle any more Protein Powder.

Try a yogurt smoothie! I put a scoop of unflavored protein powder in it, but you wouldn't have to. Here are some options, I play with the yogurt flavors and fruit, but I find I can get them down better than the premixed shakes.


Laura[emoji1]

[smileeangel 9]

Try a yogurt smoothie! I put a scoop of unflavored Protein powder in it, but you wouldn't have to. Here are some options, I play with the yogurt flavors and fruit, but I find I can get them down better than the premixed shakes.< a href="https://s.bariatricpal.com/uploads/monthly_2017_04/IMG_9290.JPG.3033427d41565270e9d7a74d2f324fca.JPG" data-fileid="70795" rel="">


Laura[emoji1]

Laura[emoji1]

[smileeangel 9]

My surgery date is 9 May. I have been trying different kinds of Protein drinks to see which one I like best. I like the Premier Protein pre-made chocolate and vanilla. I have heard that your taste for things changes after surgery. I hope I can still drink this because all the others were not my fave. I like the Isopure, but it is super expensive.

I'm post op day 11 and I can't believe how much my taste buds changed. I found lots of shakes I liked pre op and actually bought a couple packs and now I don't care for them. I'm hoping it's just because it's right after surgery. Advice- only buy a few to have on hand after surgery just in case!


Laura[emoji1]

[Layma 30]

I am like that with smells and tastes. I am fine the first two days but on the third day it will make me physically sick. I have jars and jars of Protein that I can't consume and are too expensive to throw away. I hate the taste and the dough like thickness of it.

Premier protein saved my life. It's not thick and it doesn't taste too sweet or some weird version of chocolate. It's just perfect.

[MzCoffee 23]

6 hours ago, Dianeo said:

I have been using unjury unflavored Protein Powder. It's wonderful. The flavor truly is "unflavored" and does not change the flavor of whatever you mix it with.

Me too. I'm having my gastric sleeve surgery next week and I hate that chemical/artificial taste of most flavored Protein powder.

(Exceptions to that rule are Tara's whey in Bourbon Vanilla and BioChem in Vanilla.) But I mostly prefer unflavored protein powder and agree that Unjury is truly unflavored. It is also on my hospital's recommended protein powders list.

[char3672 292]

I am still pre-op, but I have been trying out alot of different shakes so I can find one I like before surgery. I found Jay Robb Protein Shakes, they are SO GOOD! Taste just like chocolate milk. I've tried choc, vanilla and strawberry, they are ALL REALLY GOOD! I got mine from their website(you can buy single packets to try), but they also sell them on Amazon. Good luck.

[biginjapan 647]

On 4/15/2017 at 2:42 PM, HeatherS. said:

Try as I might, I just can't de-lump the powders successfully.

What powders are you using, and how are mixing them up? All my "thick" shakes go in the blender - I've never had a problem with clumping. Similarly, the nectar powders go into a Blender Bottle. I never drink the (nectar) shake immediately after mixing - there will always be a few lumps. But if you let it sit for 10-30 minutes and shake it a few times then the clumps disappear and the foaming is almost non-existent by then too.

[1poundatatime 174]

On 4/15/2017 at 5:27 PM, smileeangel said:

Laura

Thanks for these ideas!!

[mxpxchik11 48]

I was totally fine with the shakes until one day last week. I simply couldn't choke it down. I threw the last of it out. The thought of taking another sip was nauseating.

So, I'm experimenting and seeing how much Protein I can take in without them. Hopefully it will be enough, because I honestly don't think I can handle any more protein powder.

That is just what happen to me! It is not just the grit of the shake, I actually don't like the flavor any more. I bought unflavored protein but I can still taste it and it's gross! I now have a shelf full of protein powder I can't drink. I also am having so much trouble with my multi Vitamin, all of a sudden I get sick to my stomach after chewing it. I wonder if after a while it will change again??