Bike or Elliptical Trainer?

[BlooEyez 13]

I'm debating on whether to purchase a stationary bike or an elliptical trainer in order to get some exercise in while at home during the day with my kids. Anyone have any thoughts or feedback as to which would be more beneficial?

[areellady 1]

I of course would say bike, but then again, I am a biking fanatic. I am sure most people are going to tell you elliptical though. Good luck!!! Deanna

[brandottie01 0]

I loove my elliptical! I have one with magnetic resistance though so it doesn't hurt my joints too much. Although I love bikes too, I prefer the elliptical.

[Angels 0]

I love my Nordick Trak elliptical. It is just like the commercial ones at the gym. You also burn more calories with it.

[BlooEyez 13]

Maybe I should get both

[TerriDoodle 6]

I like them both! I work out at a gym, though. If I had to choose one over the other, I'd definitely choose the elliptical....you get a better workout.

[babygrl1234 6]

I am with D. I would go with the bike. But again like D, I am a bit biased.

[losingjusme 12]

i use both at my gym and am starting to really enjoy the bike as well. i tend to stay on longer when i am on the bike, but work harder when i am on the elliptical.

i am looking at ellipticals for my house though. i need a really good one.