Thoughts on Sugar free ice cream?

[Pillar2butterfly 391]

Got my family to switch from regular ice cream to sugar free...my question is...am I allowed to eat it too? Serving size is 1/2 c I think, but I doubt I could eat that much. I'm not worried about starting to crazy sweets, but occasionally I'd like a treat that I wouldn't be on my knees praying to the WLS powers to not let me gain weight!

NUT also told me turkey Jerky or beef jerky are good options, but I saw the sodium content and mentally ran screaming....thoughts on that??

[The Candidate 3,215]

For me personally, I think it would be the gateway portal to other bad things. The same way that I try and steer away from Protein Bars. Too much like candy bars for me. And I'm always afraid of the time when I can't stop at one.

[Veronica_mm 87]

If it's sugar free, why not???

Idk if we are actually allowed that, I don't see why not. Switching to sugar free EVERYTHING is quite an accomplishment itself. I'm gonna ; ) 1/2 cup factored into my day and calorie plan. Why not

[CowgirlJane 14,260]

one of the side effects of the sleeve for me was lactose intolerance. 1-2 bouts of horrible stomach cramps cured me of my ice cream cravings!

I think we each need to decide what "treats" we can afford without it triggering hunger or overeating. I was hardcore during weight loss phase because I had SO MUCH TO LOSE and wanted to get to my goal. I think plenty of people work in treats and still lose successfully. I dunno about sugar free, depends what the replacement is...

[Bufflehead 6,358]

sugar free ice cream is not allowed on my plan. It triggers cravings and doesn't have a lot of nutritional value. For treats, I like full-fat Greek yogurt with PB2 stirred in, or dried fruit, or nuts like sweet & spicy pecans or sesame-honey almonds.

[BLERDgirl 6,417]

I don't do artificial sugars of any kind. The trade off is usually higher fat or a science project of chemicals. I have taken greek yogurt, added Protein Powder or fruit or nut butter in them and put it in the freezer until it got really thick like soft serve ice cream. We all have our thing we miss. This hits my craving for ice cream without derailing my eating.

[Nylaj 45]

sugar free ice-cream is on my list that is okay, but it states to check the fat & calories.

I always eat sugar free Popsicles.

[Tssiemer1 549]

Yeah sugar free stuff usually has a lot of carbs or fat in my experience. I just looked at Sugar free Reece's cups at Walgreens and carbs were ridiculous.

[livvsmum 2,369]

I avoided sugar free ice cream mainly because of the amount of carbs in it. I did try it once fairly early on and it made me terribly sick. After that I stuck to sugar free popsicles or Jello. :-)

[VSGAnn2014 12,992]

If it's sugar free, why not???

Idk if we are actually allowed that, I don't see why not. Switching to sugar free EVERYTHING is quite an accomplishment itself. I'm gonna ; ) 1/2 cup factored into my day and calorie plan. Why not

I'll tell you why not:

* There's virtually no nutrition in that food -- and it's "expensive" for the calories that are in it (I'm guessing around 150 calories for a half-cup). That's a lot of calories. For 150 calories, you could eat more Protein, some very nutritious veggies and fruits, and even a little whole grain. The point to WLS is not just to lose weight any old way, but to get healthier. (I realize you may not care about this, but I did.)

* It indeed may be a gateway drug -- and lead to a second, third, fourth half-cup serving. .

* The sugar alcohols in there (that sweeten it) will give you diarrhea of the worst kind. Try eating two half-cups and see what happens.

Best to you.