American Idol 2007

[Paula78 0]

Ok so what is up with Barry Gibbs voice last night? He sounded like ass!

Anyway I think the right person was picked to go home! Now it gets tough, because although Melinda is damn good she lacks personality. Every song she ever sings Ive never heard of. Anyway I would love for it to be Jordin! Blake would be ok too. Jordin is so young that she could have a great career. She could change it up enough to make her liked by alot of genere's. I dont think Melinda would do that!

[maudeispam 2]

Ok so what is up with Barry Gibbs voice last night? He sounded like ass!

Anyway I think the right person was picked to go home! Now it gets tough, because although Melinda is damn good she lacks personality. Every song she ever sings Ive never heard of. Anyway I would love for it to be Jordin! Blake would be ok too. Jordin is so young that she could have a great career. She could change it up enough to make her liked by alot of genere's. I dont think Melinda would do that!

I feel the same way. Jordin should win. Blake is okay, but not my style, but he will go far! Melinda is very good, but get with the program girl. She reminds me of a lounge singer or someone on the Loveboat. JMO

[smatyas 0]

Is Blake going home tonight?

[Paula78 0]

As much as I hate to say it I do think he'll be the one to go home tonight. I believe it will be Jordin and Melinda for the final two. And I hope like hell that Jordin wins it.

[teacher 1]

I hate to say it...cause I know you're gonna crucify me....but, I thought Jordin was awful last night. Blake was great, but MELINDA.......rocked!! She brought it home last night and I hope she wins!!! (the no-neck thing isn't a problem anymore with those new wighats!!)

She is absolutely the most talented one left. Jordin seems really cocky lately...and Blake is very one dimensional.

Don't shoot me!!!

Former Music Teacher and Performer

[Paula78 0]

Youre right Melinda rocked. She always does, but omg shes so boreing. Jordin though is still my fav! I just hope that the rest of america agrees with me, because she didnt do as well as I would have liked her to have. The thing is it doesnt really matter who wins, you know they'll all have an album out soon.

[marjon9 6]

Sanjaya!!!

[Paula78 0]

Sanjaya!!!

NOOOOOOOOOOO:rofl:

[Teachlady 3]

That's it.. Idol is a big rip off. You take the most talented, consistent singer in the competition and she's gone???? Sure, I like Jordin, but Melinda was the best singer in the group. She proved it again with her farewell song. Yes, she'll do well, but dang it.... the one I pick NEVER wins!!! arghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Did I mention I'm going to my 5th Clay Aiken concert in July??

[teacher 1]

AWWW I'm sad. I liked Melinda, and Clay, and Katherine McPhee! I never seem to pick the winners! But, I KNOW a good voice when I hear one!!! Jordin will probably take it now, What do you think?

[KariK 0]

I've thought all along it will be Jordan. Blake is great, but Jordan has the pipes! I just think in a recording studio, take away the nerves and she's going to be phenominal like others such as Whitney, Mariah, Celine etc.

[Paula78 0]

:clap2:I am sooooo happy! Im glad Melinda got the boot! This almost makes up for Chris Daughtry getting kicked off last year, almost!

Rock on Jordin and Blake. I'll be happy whoever wins now!

[missy4gordon 0]

:clap2:I am sooooo happy! Im glad Melinda got the boot! This almost makes up for Chris Daughtry getting kicked off last year, almost!

Rock on Jordin and Blake. I'll be happy whoever wins now!

TOTALLY!!! I am thrilled!!!

Now it will be an awesome finale!!!

GO Blake!!!

:clap2:

[*susan* 1,709]

I had to check in on this thread, I was so tired last night, I fell asleep on the couch at 8:30 and slept right through it. Thank goodness for Tivo! But, I couldn't wait until tonight to see who was voted off, so I had to come here and check. I am pretty shocked that Melinda is gone. But, I think she will do great regardless, she has an awesome voice. I like Jordin and Blake, but am rooting for Blake because he is more "today". Plus, he is a cutie!

[Woodys 0]

I can't believe that Melinda was voted off last night. She is the only one who has consistently displayed talent, showmanship, stage presence, professionalism, etc. Blake and Jordin are talented and entertaining in their own right, but Melinda was clearly a pro.

What a pity that votes based on "being cute" and "being younger" matter more to some than actual "talent".

Carol