Lap vs Bypass

[alicat3924 0]

Did everyone on here know that they do the bypass laproscopically?

I did not know that, and now I am wondering if I should have done that proceedure, I did the lap-band because I didn't want a big scar-cut, as I already have had a c-section.

I am really curious to know if I just didn't do my homework and if everyone knows this or is it just me?

[Parvathi 2]

I didn't know that, but for me, the decision came down to a) the band is reversible :peep: the band does not reroute anything c) the band has no dumping d) the band is a safer, more effective, procedure in the long run.

We may not lose as fast as the other guys, but it comes off in the end. Guess it all just depends on what you're looking to get out of it?

[christa94 0]

yep. i knew both could be perform laproscopically. but, i liked the idea of the band being reversible and that pregnancy should be no issue since if you need to you could get any fill unfilled until after the pregnancy. plus the bypass is permanent and alot of people that get that done, restretch their new stomach over time and are right back where they started. with the band you get fills that help continue to give you restriction over time. and there was no way with a lower bmi and no co-morbidities would someone do the bypass on me!

[giveyouthemoon 4]

Yep, I knew. It's been a long time since they did RNY with the "open" methodology.

I got the band because like others I didn't like my internals getting rerouted and the band has a longer term "adjustment" feature.

My doctors really tell RNY patients that they have one year to get the weight off. After the year mark, the stomach relaxes and it gets really tough to lose.

The band has continuing adjustment capabilities. Plus if I don't like it, I get it taken out and all my guts are where they are supposed to be.

I think RNY vs band comes down to a matter of personal preference.

I suggest you do A LOT more research before making a decision.

[jcbydesign 0]

Yes most bypass surgeries are done laparoscopically. But, I'd still rather have the lapband. Too many problems with the bypass...too many returns to the hospital for this and that...sometimes very serious.

But...everyone has to do what they think best for them.

[Dani-X 0]

Did everyone on here know that they do the bypass laproscopically?

I did know that as one of the girls in my extended circle of friends had it done.

I chose the band for many reasons and I'm glad I did... bypass couldn't hold a candle to it in my opinion.

[princess_n_thep 2]

I also knew, but I chose the band for the reversability. However, I didn't know the band was long term not life long. I would have chosen bypass had I thought about it. I want something forever with no additional surgeries.

[giveyouthemoon 4]

However, I didn't know the band was long term not life long.

Hmmmm....where are you hearing that? My surgeon tells me it is lifelong as long as I take care of it. He says the silicone band will outlive me....

Is this based on seeing folks here lose their bands or are you hearing this detail elsewhere?

: curious :

[*susan* 1,709]

My surgeon also said my band is in there for life as long as we take care of each other.

[beachgirl 2]

Me too,

I don't want my stomach cut in half and intestines rerouted. I don't want the dumping, male absorption, and in a year in quit working. I've had two people who live with 30 min. of me die from the bypass. One was in intensive care on life support for over 30 days. She was 30 the other for 41. I love the band's adjustibility, the always there for you and the continued weight loss. No question in my mind. Band only.

[sleepyjean 0]

Did everyone on here know that they do the bypass laproscopically?

I did not know that, and now I am wondering if I should have done that proceedure, I did the lap-band because I didn't want a big scar-cut, as I already have had a c-section.

I am really curious to know if I just didn't do my homework and if everyone knows this or is it just me?

I knew about it. Actually, I'm a bit surprised that your surgeon never mentioned it to you. Or did you go in wanting the band and never really discussed bypass with him/her?

[HarleyNana 10]

Bypass was NEVER an option for me at my surgery weight. The thought of all the rearranging and no turning back scared me to death. Hopefully, I will keep my band for years to come.

[milagrosarroyo@yahoo.com 0]

yeah i found out when i went to the seminar you should go to one if get some free time

[lil miss scare all 0]

my doctor still keeps asking me if " im sure" about lap band , as opposed to bypass. he says " its not too late to change your mind" . ( im scheduled to have my lapband on feb. 19 ) I hate the way he asks me that. It really makes me second guess my choice and makes me wonder if he maybe knows something i dont know? I dont want to fail. I want to choose the right surgery for me. Does anyone have any suggestions on how to make this decision? Dont say to do my research, because believe me when i say I HAVE !! but the bottom line is that i really dont care which one. I kind of like the less invasive-ness of the lap band, but Im open to everyones opinion. I only want to have WLS once.

[alicez 0]

Laparoscopic Gastric Bypass, Roux en-Y: A proven efficient operation, with spectacular weight loss, 2 - 3 day hospital stay, and low risk of morbidity and mortality.

Laparoscopic Adjustable Silicone Gastric Banding: A less confirmed process, with slower and less dramatic weight loss, 1-2 day hospital stay, and the lowest risk of morbidity and mortality.

If shorter hospital stay, compact discomfort and disability, and superior cosmetic results are important to your assessment, the choice of Laparoscopic Gastric Bypass or Lap Band is a choice you should consider.

Hope this will helps you...

Edited January 28, 2009 by alicez