First Nutritionist Appt Yesterday -- Surprises

[gustavo52974 369]

The "one year" is just a window of time where the weight loss is the easiest. It is certainly ideal to focus on getting to goal during that year, but it isn't absolutely necessary. My Dr called it the honeymoon stage. He said take advantage of it, because once it's over....it's over. But to say you can never lose a pound after that is ridiculous.

I completely agree with you. But, I'm not sure why you're quoting me here...I did know what her NUT was talking about when I read her post, I just thought that a mandated deadline of one year was meaningless.

[Catracks 865]

This is definitely what she meant but my question to her (which she didn't really address) was what about the people who have to lose say 200 pounds -- is it reasonable to think they will lose 200 pounds in one year? I'm sure weight loss continues. I didn't mean to imply that I thought she meant," ok, year is over, you're done" I just was surprised that she came at it from almost a negative position instead of saying, hey the first year is where you will have the most success so lets make sure you get the most bang for your buck.

Quite a few surgeon and nutritionists do basically believe just that. From your initial post it appears that she either believes this or is trying to impress something upon you. If someone wasn't educated about the sleeve ... they might be inclined to take her at her literal word.

Yes, there are people here who lose that much in a year. It seems that the more you have to lose, the faster you will lose at the beginning, but that is not always the rule. I think maybe we lose at the same percentage, but in heavier people it equals more weight.

Somebody correct me if I'm wrong.

Check out the board specific to loosing 200+ pounds.

[Butterthebean 8,146]

I completely agree with you. But' date=' I'm not sure why you're quoting me here...I did know what her NUT was talking about when I read her post, I just thought that a mandated deadline of one year was meaningless.[/quote']

No reason, I was just building upon what you said.

[aviiva 140]

You are right about the percentage. My friend and I figured it out because I was complaining how.people were losing faster and more then me but when I figured out the percentage on someone who weighed more the percentage was just about the same

Sent from my SPH-D700 using VST

[crowell823 2]

My doctor told me that i have a year to train my body to be healthy and active...after that first year its a little harder to do if you spend the first year eating junk and whatever and not excercising....