I have a story close to yours....I have Aetna PPO and I just finished my 6 month physician - supervised visit and Aetna denied me because the surgeon faxed over for my 2 year BMI a date of service for 11/2008(which is not exactly 2 years and showed my BMI at 39.6). We faxed the appeal yesterday with a date of service my physician gave us for 05/08/08 with a BMI of 41, so what are my chances of getting approved now? I am really stressed because my scheduled surgery date is May 12th