ted12345

Just a general question here would like your honest opinion. Are Obese people unattractive and unpoular. PS, Not my views please be reasure of that.

Ok im crying again drowning in total self pitty :think I was banded in May 2005 my weight was on day of op 17 stone 5 lb. I had reduced my weight from 18 stone 5 lb on a pre op liver shrinking diet of 800cals a day for 4 week's. The actual operation was a walk in the park for me they took me to the theater at 9.30am and i was out of bed washed and dressed by 1pm. I was home 7.30am the next day potting plant's and doing light gardening feeling great. Having my band was a easier operation than having my wisdome teeth out. Well i have a very speedy idilyc recovery but begin to regain weight. By the time i have my first fill at 18 weeks post op i am back up to 17 stone 12 lb. My First fill was blind and i had 4 mills i have zero restriction so i go back 4 weeks to the date later and have another 2 1/2 mill's. This time i am tight tighter than tight and i can't drink it hurts. I emailed my fill provider but he was on holiday (vacation) by the time he get's back i have asperational pnumonia and i am very poorly. I didn't know he was on holiday and i must have emailed him 2 or 3 times i guess coming back off holiday to my winging emails annoyed his wife so she emailed me back saying the infection was not related to my band and her husband could not surgically remove pnumonia. I did ask if the infection was band related but i never for one moment think it could be band related i was worried and didn't know if it was a band related problem or what? Well three months and 2 lots of antibiotics later i am no better. I was very low and depressed by now i had sufferd all threw christmas and i was told by my family Dr i needed my band unfilled while i took time out to recover. so again and worried i emailed my fill provider and asked again for a unfill. I recived a nice reply back from his wife saying she was sorry for her comments and she explained she was tired due to just returning off holiday. So she made me a appointment for a unfill and the surgion was lovely he was a little concerd about my health and told me to return in a month. But out of the Blue my local health Authority phoned me telling me to travel to a specialist for a second opinion. I had wrote to them before christmas when my pnumonia was at its worst asking what should i do well because of the responce from the fill providers wife if it wasn't band related what was it?. So anyway it turns out it was totally band related and down to being over filled i was much better now as i had gone back and had it unfilled and from that day i began to recover. Its february now 2006 and i am almost 1 year post op the new surgion wants to x ray my band as he didn't fit it and wanted to be sure there was no slippage or anything. the x rays reveal my band is in a good position apart from me needing a fill so he filled me 2 mill's aparently i still had 2 mill's in so i am back to four mill's. I must admit being a year out and having only lost a grand total of 7 or 8lb's i was fed up. I asked the surgion would he revise my band to a bypass and he said its not that easy and he felt we should try a bit longer with the band so see if we can optimise weight loss. So off i go and back again 4 weeks later a few lb weight loss weight loss, so off i go and im back 3 months later its October now and i am gutted my weight is still at 16 stone 2lb actually a slight regain on the previous visit its a 200mile drive each way each visit all for a offical weigh in and a dissapointing 25 min consultation. I was told to go back after Christmas 9th Jan 2007. But iv had enough iv had nothing but problems i can't keep any solid food down at all i vomit everything solid. I am forsed to consume food that i can eat rather than should eat. I suffer from constant heartburn (reflux) its horrendus it feels like i have a baby elephant sat on my chest i feel short of breath and it's just uncomfortable. The motional impact of not loseing weight at almost 2 years out or should i say any kind of sygnificant weight to improve my quality of life or even impact on my comorbidtys is heartbreaking. I have socially withdrown had a recent complete breakdown resulting in a serious attempt to end my life. I took a overdose of citilopram and washed them down with alchohol i cut my wrist repetedly and went to sleep. My husband rushed me to hospital the next day when he found me in a state and he was unable to wake me. For the past 2 or three weeks my depression has nose dived i didn'tintend to harm myself i can't remember much of it or even why i did it i just felt i couldnt see a way of changing my situation and life as it is was not worth living. I am tremendusly fed up with my band. No matter how hard i struggle to get my head around it and adjust to i can't. I am constantly hungry i was told the band would make me feel full and i would feel the need to stop eating sooner. That just does not happen i feel my restriction but i do not feel full or satisfied i am hungry and if i eat anything solid it comes streght back up. I can't make the healthy options beacuse the band wont have them some days the egg's go's down other days it does not. I have began to hate myself more than ever because i am not making the correct adjustments to lose weight and i only had this band fitted to lose weight. I wanted better mobility i was told the band would cure me of my reflux problem and weight loss would improve my stress incontinents. None of this has happened and while the band is in a good position and would seem to be working fine i am not. I can't handle this constant hunger and the diet is horrendus the vomiting is horrendus i know the vomiting is because i have eaten too much but even with one bite of food im vomiting no matter how much i chew. Infact sometimes its not even a vomit if i bend over it simply just falls out of my mouth as if it has gone no further than my tonsills. The poor diet leaves me feeling lathorgic and my hair is limp and falling out. My scalp is dry and ichy and my skin is spotty and dry. chocolate crisp and rubbish go down fine sloppy food like lasgna mashed potatoes go down fine but there high carb hens no weight loss. Im begining to think im losing my own mind that the vomiting is more psycoligical than a actual banding problem. Eather way it all rounds up to im not coping and suiside right now seems like a better option than the life i am living because the i have no quality of life and the longer it go's on the more fed up i am getting the deeper into dispare i am. tomorrow i have a psyciatrist appointment iv been getting regular help since my overdose 3 weeks ago. I almost cant wait to see the shrink because i am constantly thinking of death as a way out and im having horrendus urges to but myself again. this is so knew to me i have never wanted to cut myself before. I am worried i might do myself some real harm while not really meaning to do it. I am resisting the urges but the more i dwell on my weight the more i think of self harm. and its not like i can stop thinking about it and forget weight loss for a while because the weight impacts so much on my daily life it just seems there is no escape, and now i have taken a over dose i am so worried and frustrated with myself that i will now be considerd too unstable for a bypass when at the end of the day all's i want is to lose weight and start to enjoy life. it seems ironic i am fighting to improve mylife so i can get a better quality of life but the actual fight is leaving me wishing i was dead. :think i know me me me its all about me poor old me pitty me im fed up of hearing myself winge so god knows how those around me feel.

you ether agree with the comments that obese people are NEVER popular attractive or have a life or you dont, How confusing is that??? Stick with societys negative views or just take people for what they are with out being so judgemental.

<TABLE width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD colSpan=2>The social and psychological consequences of obesi </TD></TR><TR><TD>Our society has a very negative view of overweight and obesity. Research evidence of stigma and discrimination agrees with the public values and attitudes commonly expressed by the media. They tell us that being fat is an extremely unattractive and undesirable way to be, indeed, that it is a state to be avoided at all costs. This hostility towards fatness has been compared with other common social prejudices, and the striking conclusion drawn that anti-fat attitudes are at the stage that racism was some 50 years ago; namely, that anti-fat attitudes are overt, expressible and widely held. The perception of obesity This derogatory view of obesity is not new. Some of the earliest research, published in the 1960s, examined children’s attitudes, presumably because they openly reflect prevailing adult opinion. In one of these studies 10- and 11-year old children were presented with six line drawings of a child as physically normal and with each of five physical disabilities, one being overweight. Ranking the figures by asking which they liked best resulted in a robust order of preference, with the normal child at the top, and the overweight child at the bottom, below that of a child with facial disfigurement, in leg brace and crutches, or in a wheelchair. In a second study children were asked to assign 39 adjectives to one of three silhouette drawings depicting a thin, a muscular, and a fat body shape. The obese body shape was least frequently assigned ‘best friend’, most frequently ‘gets teased’, and labelled ‘lazy, dirty, stupid, ugly, liar and cheat’ more often than the other body shapes. Subsequent research has confirmed both this order of preference and these perceived negative character traits, broadly describing the obese stereotype as greedy, lazy, of lower intelligence, and socially isolated. It also suggests that the negative response has increased rather than relaxed as might be expected given the increasing levels and public face of obesity. These two studies are important since they describe two principal features of the stigma of overweight. On one hand is the stigmatisation of bodily appearance; obesity is a highly visible but undesirable state. On the other, is the stigmatization of character; the moral view that holds the obese personally responsible for their own state and so blames them for their fatness. Further research with children has extended this characterisation and shows that even pre-adolescents have incorporated the message of poor health, fitness and eating habits in their attributions of overweight. Likewise, there are social class variations in these negative views, with the least favourable attitudes more likely to be expressed by children from higher social class backgrounds. During adolescence overweight may be an important determinant of social experience. Overweight adolescents, for example, receive fewer friendship nominations than lean peers and are less likely to be named as a friend by people they nominate. In addition, teenagers express discomfort with dating overweight peers, something particularly strongly expressed by boys. This confirmation of overweight as unattractive, unhealthy, and least acceptable in affluent social circles goes some way to explaining the high levels of body shape dissatisfactions and dieting in pre-adolescent and teenage girls. </TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR><TD> Download File </TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR><TD colSpan=2>Obesity and psychological health </TD></TR><TR><TD>Given the above catalogue of stigmatisation, a state of poor psychological health would be expected for all obese individuals. However, this is not the case. The variation in psychological adjustment among the obese is broadly comparable to that in the population at large. And there is certainly no major psychiatric disorder or specific personality disorder associated preferentially with obesity. However, there is an emerging literature linking obesity with depression. In one study, for example, over 40,000 adults were given a structured interview including an assessment of anxiety and depression as part of a National Alcohol Survey. Obesity was associated with a 37% increased risk of major depression in women but a 37% decreased risk of depression in men. There was a similar association between obesity, gender and suicide attempts – obese women at increased risk, obese men at decreased risk. Furthermore, although the association between female obesity and depression was rather modest in epidemiological terms, the researchers had controlled for depression co-occurring with physical illness or bereavement. When these were included the association between obesity and past-year depression further strengthened. In another large scale community survey in the US, obesity was significantly associated with past-month depression in women (odds ratio = 1.82) but not in men. Furthermore, there is longitudinal evidence that in people aged over 50, obesity increases the risk of developing depression. The relationship between obesity and self-esteem is not clear-cut either. In adults, obesity is associated with a modest reduction in self-esteem, sometimes limited only to those with morbid obesity. In pre-adolescent children, obesity has little or no impact on global self-esteem. In teenagers, self-perceived overweight is more closely associated with reduced self-esteem than is actual overweight. Similarly, this relationship is stronger in females than in males. Body esteem, or satisfaction with appearance, is the domain of self-worth most affected by obesity. This is especially true for obese adolescents and young women whose sense of identity is greatly dependent on appearance and in whom some show very high levels of body dissatisfaction. Again, body dissatisfaction may be more strongly associated with perceived overweight and depression, than with actual weight. Therapy aimed at improving body image in obese women has shown some success in relieving negative psychological symptoms but has little impact on body weight. Further studies of large representative samples using established measures of health-related quality of life have helped separate physical functioning from psychological health, while showing their inter-dependence. Age is an important moderator of the relationship between obesity and well-being. Overweight and obese women in their late teens and early twenties score significantly lower in physical functioning, vitality and general health, but show few differences on any of the main psychological health measures. The pattern for middle-aged women (45-49) is different. First, there are proportionately more overweight and obese women in this age group. Second, these older obese women score significantly lower than those of average weight on all the physical and psychological health scales. Most of the available evidence shows the greatest deficits are in the severely or morbidly obese (BMI>40). Scores on the psychological health scales for the moderately obese (BMI 30-40) show similarity to those who are underweight (BMI<20), whereas overweight women show similarity to normal weight individuals. It is also important to take account of the co-occurrence of chronic illness. In one study, people with obesity plus other chronic health conditions (around half the obese) reported particularly poor physical and psychological health. Since this was most apparent in those with 3 or more chronic conditions it identifies an especially vulnerable group. It is also notable that among groups of people with similar levels of chronic illness, the additional presence of obesity was associated with a significant deterioration in physical but not emotional well-being. This means that past assessments of psychological well-being may have been confounded by physical health problems. It also shows that obese individuals with pain or co-occurring chronic illnesses are most at risk of psychological distress. </TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR><TD colSpan=2>Binge-eating disorder </TD></TR><TR><TD>Binge eating is one clinical problem that does appear to be more prevalent in the obese, at least in those entering weight loss programmes. The recently described syndrome of ‘binge eating disorder’ (binge eating without purging by vomiting or other means) has been described in 30% of patients attending US weight loss clinics. The use of strict diagnostic criteria reduces this to well below 20%. In community samples, BED is much less common, apparent in only 1-3% of respondents. Overall, the prevalence of BED in any group increases with increasing obesity. Interestingly, up to half describe their binge eating as preceding their obesity, rather than arising as a consequence of extreme dieting, the pattern most commonly found in bulimia nervosa. Attitudes of health professionals Given what has been written above it should be no surprise that the attitudes and beliefs of health professionals reflect those of the wider community. Thus research shows that doctors and medical students are likely to share the moralistic view that obese people are weak-willed, ugly, less competent and likeable, and less likely to benefit from counselling. Bias has also been observed in nurses and nursing students, nutritionists and psychologists. Even health professionals who specialise in obesity show anti-fat biases. They mask overtly negative responses but measures of implicit attitudes reveal the culturally prevalent stereotyping. One important question is whether professionals’ views of overweight have consequences for the medical process. Some time ago it was noted that doctors were more likely to note a weight problem and recommend a treatment programme for women than men. More recently, obese women were found more likely to be misclassified as having coronary heart disease than non-obese women. In addition, the prescribing of lipid lowering medication by British general practitioners has been found less likely in overweight people, with doctors explicitly stating this as their policy. However, the most apparent consequence is the reluctance of obese individuals to seek medical care. This is not restricted to consultations about weight loss but has been observed in decreased use by obese women of preventive health care services such as breast screening. This reluctance could be because obese individuals are aware of the negative attitudes of medical professionals towards people such as themselves. It also may be the result of body self-consciousness, or past experience of health professionals attributing health problems to the obesity. Additionally, doctors may be disinterested in managing overweight patients, in part based on their perceived futility in bringing about weight loss in a group with little presumed will-power. </TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR><TD colSpan=2>The effects of weight change </TD></TR><TR><TD>The effects of weight loss on improving feelings of well-being and self-esteem have been reported many times. This may be especially marked when some form of physical exercise or activity has been part of the weight loss strategy. Indeed, relatively modest reductions in weight can improve general psychological health. However, the mixture of individuals who enter a weight control programme will experience a mixture of psychological repercussions. These will include, pride in their success and a feeling of mastery, annoyance at the difficulties in adjusting their routine to ensure weight loss, despair at apparent failure, and anger and frustration at the effort that has to be expended. Significant and sustained weight loss is not easy for the great majority to achieve. Weight regain is usually associated with loss of psychological gains, although one study at least has shown the psychological benefits of weight loss to remain with full weight regain. The relationship between weight loss and mood is a complicated one and an issue that is not limited to obesity. Of relevance here though is the observation that greater and faster weight losses are associated with poorer mood outcomes. Specifically, nearly half of the studies with a mean weight loss of greater than 9 kg (20 lb) have reported aversive mood consequences. In contrast, there are none in those with smaller weight losses. A related issue is that of weight cycling, or the phenomenon of repeatedly losing and regaining weight, noted as frequent in both overweight and non-overweight individuals. The very few studies that have examined the psychological consequences are consistent in showing that those with a history of weight cycling have significantly more psychological problems, lower levels of satisfaction with life, and more eating disorder symptoms than those who are weight stable. In addition, obese binge eaters have been found to have more past weight cycling episodes than obese non-binge eaters. However, the research cannot yet distinguish whether it is the weight cycling that causes these psychological problems, whether the problems themselves lead to intensified dieting but weight regain, or that weight cycling and psychological problems are correlated but not causally related. Attempts to identify psychological predictors of weight loss have not met with great success. As the preceding account implies, the presence of depression, anxiety or binge eating is associated with poorer weight loss, although again findings are inconsistent. Similarly, summary measures of readiness to change or motivation to lose weight have generally failed to predict outcome. In contrast, self-efficacy – a person’s evaluation of whether s/he can perform the behaviours required for weight loss – is a modest but consistent predictor of success. The need for change Obesity can have devastating psychosocial consequences. However, the mechanisms to impaired psychological health are different from those to physical illness. Two prominent researchers in the field, Stunkard and Sobal make the point very bluntly: ".... obesity does not create a psychological burden. Obesity is a physical state. People create the psychological burden." Changing people's attitudes and thus those of society will not be easy. But the analogy with racism could be used as a starting point for identifying those strategies that have been most successful in the past, and by learning from their outcome. The combination of education, science, good practice, changes in legislation, and a promotion of tolerance, are all necessary to meet this goal. The inclusion of psychological well-being as an obesity treatment goal, the activities of patient support groups, the development of training packages for health professionals, prosecutions for false weight loss product claims by trading standards officers, and test cases for discrimination under employment law would all be steps in the right direction. </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>

May be i have been very lucky in life and my weight has never effected my pulling power or made me less attractive to other people. Even with Sever dyslexia i have been very succesfull in busness also and i guess my personailty has got me threw. Ya know what the more i think about it what sad miserable lives obese people do have if they are never popular or cant find a partner or do fun things with the friends (if they have any) or children (if they have any because they are too big to to get a partner to have em!) Guess i am a exception to the rule

no no no this was all on another forum and i just wanted to ask do Big people have this general view that Big people are NEVER popular or get dates. i know personally i have never had any probs. I agree with what others said if your low in self esteem you will be miserable and negative and thats not a attractive feture. But Being Obese does not automatically make you unnatractive or unpopular.

My spelling and typing is horrendus due to sever dyslexia. i appologise for that i find this hard enough as it is so i know were your coming from. Right lets start again. I am two years banded really struggling. and wonderd if the years of o yo dieting made weight loss harder. so thats simple enough yeah? (there is history with the person who replied) But the reply to my question really does i feel insinuate that obese people Are NEVER popular or get dates or havelifes. I find that opinion of Big people in general offencive, i personally feel there is a difference between low self esteem and what sociaty makes you feel and with opinions like that no wonder some of us feel like that. I personally dont think Obese people are less atractive or popular and i know big people can lead full lives. I dont think obese people needs empty sympathy from people who view us so negetivly.

of course bloody english is my first language I AM ENGLISH!! I read the reply to insiuate that Obese people are NEVER popular get dtaes (meaning there unnatractive) or have a life IE they dont ride horses or run bloody marathons. for gods sake i have three kids one has ADHD i run abloody marathon every day just getting them ready for school. I have a stunning hunky hubby and i welth of friends. I cant see why the reply would invole these issues if they did not see them as issues. How do they have any relovence to the question? Do you reconise the person who wrote the responce?

sorry my mistake Was you a big baby and a chubby child then a over weight adult? Or was you always very slim untill you reached a certain age or had a baby or something along those lines? I have had a lifetime of weight issues i am finding it harder and harder to lose the weight. It it true yo yo dieting can mess your body up and effect the weight loss prosess? The above was my origional question, I was a healthy attractive athlete until my mid 40's. I developed Type 2 diabetes and things exploded after that in huge weight gains that I did not monitor. By the time I had Band surgery in 2005 I was 58. My brain remembered the good old days, so I started behaving like that again. The weight peeled off. I started by training and completing a half marathon. Now, after plastic surgery, my old self is coming back. I still have more surgeries and work to do, but I'm now on a positive roll that will not quit. My heart breaks over obese people who have NEVER been popular, had lots of dates, rode a horse, ran a marathon, etc. It's never too late to learn and go on. That was the reply, I feel OUT OF CONTEXT i asked if yo yo dieting made weight loss harder. The person who replied was on about how fab they was and how so call heartbroken they feel or unattractive unpopular no life obese people. I was posing a question as to wether years of serious obesity and life time diets (yo yo) dieting can effect the ability to lose weight. So i was trying to find out the differnece between people who were always slim and peeps who have always struggled. Most of us n general can lose weight only we reagain it. And this happens over and over again. But if you have been slim all your life then suddenly gain weight what changes to make you gain weight? and how hard is it loseing is it as just as hard as us people who have struggled all our lifes who do generally just find it harder and harder? Does yo yo dieting effect the ability to lose weight.

lisa the question origionally asked was not about self esteem while itotaly agree with what you say. The origional question was does years of yo yo dieting effect the ability to lose weight? kinda like if you have been big all your life fighing the fat does it just get harder and harder to lose weight. does yo yo dieting effect the matabolism and the ability to lose weight. The responce was kina out of context didnt really answer the question other than they was always "slim athletic and attractive" untill later life. The reply emphosized on NEVER being poular or getting dates or having a life. i mean they bare no referrence to the question of matabolism ? and again there is a difference about how we persive our selfs and how others persive us. As sociaty does mock the big and assumes that because some one is slim they are more attractive and popular and more likely to have successful life. I BEG TO DIFFER

The origional question was from ME i asked about yo yo dieting, so i know what i meant The reply was a shock as it bares little reference to the actual question, The questuion was about a lifetime struggle and does yo yo dieting effect the ability to lose weight.

ahhh but this is not the perspective of how we feel about our selfs, This is odviously how the poster see's obese people? surly it is beacuse how can they make such a statement if there life has never been one of obesity? I feel there is a differnece about self esteem and its effects and wether does obesity actually mean that you are less attractive and NEVER popular or cant get dates and have a life. I feel as a big girl i am farly attractive and i have a abundence of friends and often begging for forgivemess because i cant fit them all in. To a certain extenct weight has stopped me doing certain things but more my "mental state" and how i feel rather than the actual weight being the limitation. untill it began to impact on my health. This is not a opinion from a self expression this is a opinion of obese people. emphasis is put on populariety. Again we all agree that its more self esteem and self impression that leads to attractiveness and populariety not the actual weight!

Was you a big baby and a chubby child then a over weight adult? Or was you always very slim untill you reached a certain age or had a baby or something along those lines? I have had a lifetime of weight issues i am finding it harder and harder to lose the weight. It it true yo yo dieting can mess your body up and effect the weight loss prosess? That was the question posed. I feel it bares no question on Attractiveness, It was more about could or would people find it harder to lose weight who have messed up motabolisms due to years of bottleing the weight and yo yo dieting. I felt the respnce was out of context and that may be how i read it my way and i found the comments offencive. There are social problems due to weight and i feel with opinions like that is it any wonder. untill there for the grace of god go i and it happens to you.

How can they experience it? they didnt live a life of obesity?

<TABLE class=ThmBgStandard cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=10 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD>I was a healthy attractive athlete until my mid 40's. I developed Type 2 diabetes and things exploded after that in huge weight gains that I did not monitor. By the time I had Band surgery in 2005 I was 58. My brain remembered the good old days, so I started behaving like that again. The weight peeled off. I started by training and completing a half marathon. Now, after plastic surgery, my old self is coming back. I still have more surgeries and work to do, but I'm now on a positive roll that will not quit. My heart breaks over obese people who have NEVER been popular, had lots of dates, rode a horse, ran a marathon, etc. It's never too late to learn and go on. </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE> Just i came across this i found it offencive, May be i read into it to much but to me i read that Obese people are unatractive cant or dont gets dates. dont have lifes and that the poster didnt have a lifetime battle with there weight so in my opinion WLS was very much a first rather than last option, Were as MOST of us who are big try every other available method of weight loss before resorting on surgery. The person who posted that didnt try anything just gained weight and had surgery to fix it. And while they claim to be heart broken for obese people they have some very derogotary opinions of obese people. Thats how i read it. I feel there is a huge difference between suffering a lifetime of true obesity and just gaineing a few lb's in later life. We all hear that years of yo yo dieting can mess up your matabolism. So may be the person who posted that found there banding jurney fairly easy because there matabolism had not been shot to peices like most of us who have tried basically everything else all our lifes.

Some surgeons in the UK are now fitting the new Easyband, Its electronic and no need for needles when filling. Sounds allright to me but what if a emergancy unfill was needed not all the Aand E hospital departemnts would have the other device that controls the fills would they? were as a needle is fairly easily available! http://www.healthierweight.co.uk/obesity-surgery/easyband-gastric-banding

I had asperational pnumonia last year it lasted just over 3 months was horrendus to say the least. It took a complete unfill just to be able to take anti biotics.

what drugs you on woman? read my post again and quote me ok!!! typical blinded by fear responce

But you are in a minority in the UK after care is normal to be one year and 2 band adjustments for private patients. I am a NHS patient i have life long after care. My life that is not the band if my band was to be removed tomorrow for what ever reason treatment for my obesity would continue. Were as if i was a private patient and my band had to be removed tomorrow. I would have to fund that band removal and i would have lost a huge amount of money and prob be no better off for it. Statistically after care packages are 12 months, You do know that i am sure and in europe were they have been doing banding for many years they are seeing long term results and like geezersue said the problems are usually 2 years +. Fortuantly some people never experience problems but thats not the case for a lot of bandsters. Thats not to say the band should be totally written off. Just that the facts and figures are there and no amount of individuals saying im fine changes the statistics that the band has a reported 30+ faliour rate. and high complication rate long term. Would seem the smooth riders are begining to be the minority.

I would like to offer moral support in the aspect of regain. Try to remember Obesity is a life long issue and while a band can help even if we unbanded a lot of our great losers a lot of them would regain there lost weight. Thats why the band is designed to stay in for ever and not just untill you are at goal. While distressing its very normal and to be expected to regain if the band is removed often we have not adjusted sugnificatly enough to cope without a little extra help.

So far 30 people with probs and 80 with none thats almost half allready even with a small flawed survey the results speak for them selfs.

I agree with what geezersue said, I read that if the pateint has not lost 25% of excess weight after 2 years thats a band faliour. So even with no complications it can take upto two years to get a good picture of what band results are. I also am curious as to why surgery providers usually only offer a 1 years after care package if the band is and should last a lifetime? If the statistics showed better long term results i think they would be confidently able to offer a longer after care package with the knowledge that complications are rare. sadly there not and by the time problems develope the patients after care package has expired.

I am a bit out of date here aint i lol A lady has died in the UK as a direct result of the Lapband, food got stuck and if i remember correctly problems beveloped with the stomach and she died. I'll have look around see if i can find the story for ya. It would have been so easy to save her life if a surgeon had gone in and just snipped the band lose. i remeber it said she was in hospital 3 days and no one actually ever attemted to contact the surgeon who fitted the band. he was quoted to have said that had they contacted him he could have talked any surgeon threw unfilling the band or even just snipping the band. Ill have a look for the news report.

If you look at any research there is lists of names, From EU, UK and US surgeons. In fact surgeons from all over the world while it is not ideal some one should travel out of there country for surgery i think surly they cant all be wrong. I mean if there all wrong why do they colaberate there findings and all meet up at functions and so on. I dont think every surgeon from abroad id dodgy i am dubious about a surgeon that can reconise problems with patients who had banding abreoad but boasts a 100% sucess rate for himself. When in reality there are many of his patients struggling. seems ironic he can spot some one elses mistake but not his own. I think the key is you have lost weight and now doubt has been set in your mind. May be you need more fills why shouldnt they work if to date you have lost weight. Try not to worry about it like you say enjoy the christmas season. Try and remember this season has lots of temptations about for us more than normal. and it can be hard sticking to the rules while everry one else kicks back and relaxes. If you have a few classes of wine more than normal thats all calories in. I Think we shouldnt be too hard on our selfs this time of year as we shouldnt socially exclude our selfs after all isnt that one of the reasons we all want to lose weight so we can get out and enjoy life more to the full with higher self esteem.

Mr Kahn is at walsall mannor Hospital, You should not feel bad about going abroad at the end of the day look at me and look at some of his other patients were not doing to great so he isnt so super AT ALL. Your band may be placed wrong it may not be. But i think you have lost weight and has now but doubt in your head and i suspect this has given your confidence a kickin and motivation isnt as good as it was. I cant believe he charged you £400 for a x ray fill that way above adverage at most it should have been £250 and yes you have every right to have those x rays. who's to say he just said that so he could wip you in fit a new one and charge you a fortune for it? We only have his word there is no x ray to prove it. i see Mr Dexter now at Leeds Nuffield my PCT pay for it, There is also Mr diggory in Telford he is lovely and its only a 30 min drive to Telford. He's at the apley clinic Telford. Mr Dexter is at leeds Nuffield. Mr Kahn at walsall Manor Walsall. Mr Patel is at the guthrie clinic London. choose any one and see if your GP can refer you and get you sorted. I know My PCT have paid for Mr diggory and Mr Dexter and iv seen them in the private sector but NHS funded. I have heard others say Mr Super is arrogant, If you need any help email me ill give you some contact details but your GP should esily be able to reffer you to any one of these consultants. And they will apply for NHS funding for you. Please dont believe the band is situatied in the wrong position untill you have it from some one you trust!.