Hello,
I've been reading these boards but this is my first post. I have Anthem BCBS so I thought I'd share my store here too.
So basically, I followed the less is more approach. We sent in 4 pages, a one page letter from my doctor, a one page letter from my pysch, a one page write-up from the nutrition counselor, and one page from the surgeon. Sent it in on the 19th and got approved on the 26th.
I truly think not sending in all the extra paper is why I got approved so quickly. I wouldn't recommend sending in anything they don't ask for. Anthem BCBS PPO only asks for a PCP note, Nutritional counseling (a simple letter will do), and a pysch eval. (a simple letter will do). There is also a form they have for the surgeon to fill out.
It was so quick and easy I was surprised.