Thanks everyone...I actually have call in to a different surgeon..one my step sister and her friend see. One had the band for years...didnt do so well with it...took a year and half to loose 70lbs and then it slipped...so she had bypass 2 weeks ago and says she wished she had done bypass to begin with. The thought of waiting a few more months makes me want to cry but I want to make to right choice. I dont want to waste another year with the band if it isnt going to do the job. I see some have done wonderful with it..and if I cold be gaurenteed a seat in that club then my choice would be clear. But there are no gaurentees with the band. I appreciate the feed back everyone. Youve all helped....I will keep you posted with my decision!!