I haven't gotten my band yet but I hope to. We all are different, everyone don't react the same to the same things. Some it will work for others it won't. There are exceptions to every rule. How many times have we been told to try a product because this one, that one and the other one tried it and lost weight but it didin't work for us. For those who that happened to you were the exception to the rule. I'm glad you posted that, it's a good help for my research.