I'm new to the band as well. My surgery date was in October..I really thought i would have lost more weight than i have not extreme weight but a good 30lbs at least. I have had 2 fills so far doc appointment tomorrow. I knew the band wasnt magic but i did expect more from it so i guess i have to hold tight and see want happens by the 6 months-1yr to tell if it is some bs or not. But best wishes to you in what ever you decide to do!!!