Update -My daughter did have surgery. Her second appeal was denied but the company I work at and my benefits department helped me greatly as my company is self insured. I also found out that Highmark covered the surgery for other patients with a BMI less than 50. Don't give up, I know how much it sucks and how heart breaking it is but it is worth it in the long run. My daughter is 8 weeks post op and has lost 45 pounds so far. It is like she is a new person already, much happier. I am so glad we did not switch procedures and go to the Lap Band. I don't know that she would have the best results with that. We probably would have gone with a Roux en Y if she would not have gotten approved for the sleeve. Good luck everyone