Kimmom-- I can relate to your situation. I have been very private about my own banding. My parents and siblings know, but not my inlaws. I know how you feel. Chris NJ is obviously very comfortable with his situation, which I commend greatly. I wish I could be that way. Yes it is true that it is obvious to everyone that I am overweight, yet I am an EXTREMELY private person and does not want everyone knowing my business. I feel that this is a long road that I want to travel alone with only my closest VERY SUPPORTING family and husband. I didn't want to deal with all the questions of what can you eat how much have you lost, etc. It does make me feel really good when people notice that I have lost weight, and when they ask how I tell them fitness center and cutting back on what I eat. Which is the truth. As far as what your husband did, I don't blame you for being upset. Because he told something that was very sacred and private that you asked him not to. As to why he did no one but he knows. He may feel pressured by his FIL to knoww all of your business and didn't feel he would stop until he knew. As far as your FIL goes next time he asks tell him you appreciate his concern but for now you would prefer to not discuss it with everyone. P.S. My best friend doesn't know either.