Jump to content
×
Are you looking for the BariatricPal Store? Go now!
Sign in to follow this  
  • entry
    1
  • comments
    6
  • views
    1,551

Evidenced Based Medicine?

3yearsleeve

748 views

I recently joined this site to provide my experience with the sleeve. Like many of you, I can remember going to my first patient which would be the start of my new life. I had decided that I was going to get a Lap-Band or a Sleeve, I chose the sleeve. One of the reasons was due to the fact that patients who were both 6 months post op with the sleeve (Gary and Jenny) dropped nearly 70lbs without having to reroute the intestines....they were so, so happy and healthy looking! At that time many insurance companies were not covering the sleeve, luckily or not so lucky, my insurance company did cover it after a two month fight.

 

Well, needless to say but Gary, Jenny and I are all looking at having a second procedure, which will most likely be a DS and or Bypass. At the time we all trusted our surgeon which is why I'm starting this blog. YOU are the only one who is responsible for this MAJOR decision and I can't believe what I was not told and what I have found out 3 years later. See below and make sure you do your own research on this procedure.

 

1) 80% of your stomach will be taken out of your body - can never be reversed - like a Bypass (Difficult) or Band (Very Easy for a BS to Remove a Band).

 

2) Currently there hasn't been a single randomized controlled study out to 5 years demonstrating the Gastric Sleeve to be effective - Currently there are two sleeve studies, one out to 18 months and another out to 1 year which to no ones surprise show EXCELLENT EWL. (Bypass and Band Have Numerous 5 year data sets, which have been published is NEJM, Lancet and Jama - Most well respected and trustworthy PEER REVIEWED JOURNALS (Both show sustained and durable weight loss at 5 years).

 

3) Also, if you have time check out the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid and their position statement about the lack of creditable long term data (5 years)/



6 Comments


Recommended Comments

I've studied this for so long, I feel like an expert. There are a lot of people several years out who have not regained their weight. You stated the risks correctly, but I believe that weight regain is fairly uncommon with a sleeve. I sure hope I am right. Good Luck with your next procedure.

Share this comment


Link to comment

3yrssleeve,

Based on the info you provided in your profile, it looks like you lost 120 lbs at 18 months post-sleeve, then by 3 yrs out had gained back 100 lbs. Is that about right?

If you don't mind sharing with us, what do you feel most contributed to the re-gain? How different do you things things would be now (weight and health-wise) if you had decided on a different procedure initially or no procedure at all?

I ask with great personal interest since my sleeve is scheduled for Oct 25th. And yes, I am aware of the lack of quality, peer-reviewed published long-term outcomes data with the sleeve relative to band or bypass.

Your comments and story would be most helpful. Thanks.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

PatchAid Vitamin Patches

×