Well, I think it comes down to what fits you the best. I would have loved to do the sleeve, but insurance paid for LapBand and I am okay with that. I plan on getting banded in the next couple of months. I like the fact that it is adjustable (and, if you plan on having any kids, that may be something to consider), that is the least invasive surgery, and that the weight loss is slower (to help with the extra skin).

I have another friend who had the sleeve done in Mexico because her insurance didn't pay for WLS. She didn't want to pay each time she had a fill. Her weight loss was quite dramatic. She had it done 2 1/2 years ago and went from 270 (at her heaviest) to 125. She didn't have any complications. She could only eat a bite or two at each meal and took vitamins to supplement. She also followed a strict sugar free diet.

No matter what, both are great surgeries and I'm sure you will come to a wonderful decision no matter what. Good luck!

thanks for your post... what about the things the Dr. never tells you... post surgery... what about...

loud stomach noises, gurgling? I do skincare and treatment room is very quiet.

what is dumping??

what about poop? all this liquid... do we poop like normal or is all soft. ? IBS much??

My choice was made for me by insurance. I've heard good things about the sleeve, but my experience will be based on the band.

The fills? Not hard to deal with. But if you are paying for each one than I'd account for 3-4 year 1 (if you are looking at total cost analysis). The burping? Not a big issue. The stuck episodes? My fault. Pooping? You are making a major change in your food intake. This will be impacted no matter what WLS surgery you select. I had a tendency toward IBS before the band, and as I've improved my eating patterns it has become much better. Gas? Not so much better lol. But after buying stock in GasX I'm in a much better place with that.... Also I attribute a lot of that to eating more vegetables.

In my opinion, most of what you read on this site is people looking for advice and information, not necessarily complaining. As I look back over the last 3 months I can honestly say I have no regrets at all, and I think the band is a great option for me.

I did a lot of online (and book) research. I'd recommend taking those steps before making a decision. Best wishes in your process!

thank you so much for your posts. qtney - I'm interested in contacting your friend - is possible to ask her to email me at catalina139@hotmail.com. much appreciate it. thanks!! and thanks sandradee, your posts are always helpful and upbeat. kt